
If Sarah Gailey wasn’t so damn good at what they do, they’d be downright annoying. Why do I say that? Glad you asked! My point is, Gailey’s literary output, from American Hippo to When We Were Magic, from Magic for Liars to The Echo Wife, from Upright Women Wanted to Just Like Home, is so breathtakingly varied that it puts other writers to shame. Every book I’ve read by them is a unique experience. The only thing they have in common is the uniformly stellar quality of the writing.
Make Me Better continues that tradition.
This is twisted, complex, slow-burn psychological horror novel, a masterclass in how a lonely, depressed person can be seduced and gaslit. Celia is yearning for a sense of belonging, and Kindred Cove is a seemingly idyllic island community that promises healing, moral improvement, even transformation. As she finds herself immersed in the group, Gailey uses shifting perspectives and assorted timelines to slowly reveal the disturbing dynamics beneath the surface, the monstrous rot at the center of the community. Celia wants to be seen as good, as worthy, and Kindred Cove seems to offer a path forward through brutal, unsettling forms of devotion. It should be mentioned that Kindred Cove is set on an island surrounded by a mysterious, ever-growing reef that the community seems to have an unnatural affinity for.
The most important word in the above paragraph may be transformation. Gailey is concerned with transformation in every sense of the word. Mental, emotional, and perhaps most importantly, physical. While Gailey has always had a rare gift for characterization and superlative storytelling, they show an equally rare gift for body horror with Make Me Better.
Make Me Better isn’t an easy book. It gives up its secrets slowly, skipping back and forth across the years, layering the horror like a master painter adding brushstrokes. But for the careful reader, it’s richly rewarding. This is one of Gailey’s best, and that’s saying something.
Make Me Better will be published on May 12, 2026, and is available for preorder now.































